Panna, Peridot or Green Onyx? Choosing a Budh Stone by Budget

Panna (emerald) is the main gemstone of Budh (Mercury) in Vedic astrology. It is not the only Budh stone, though. Peridot and green onyx are the two substitutes (uparatna) people ask us about most. This guide compares the three on the things that actually change your decision: what each stone is, who it suits, and roughly what a typical stone costs at Tushar Gems.
Short answer: if your kundli calls for Panna and your budget allows it, a certified natural Panna is the first choice. Green onyx is the low-cost option, often used as a first trial. Peridot sounds like the middle path, but at our store a good peridot costs about the same per ratti as an entry-level Panna, so compare the two before you decide.
The three Budh stones side by side
| Stone | What it is | Rate per ratti (our stock) | A 5 ratti stone, approx. |
|---|---|---|---|
| Panna (Emerald) | Natural beryl, the main ratna of Budh | ₹3,400 – ₹21,400 (most stones ₹5,600 – ₹10,800) | ₹17,000 for an entry stone; most stones ₹28,000 – ₹54,000 |
| Peridot | Natural olivine, a Budh uparatna | About ₹3,600 – ₹5,600 | About ₹18,000 – ₹28,000 |
| Green Onyx | Natural chalcedony, the most common Budh uparatna | About ₹450 | About ₹2,250 |
Based on the certified stones listed on tushargems.com in October 2026 (32 green onyx and 7 peridot stones, plus our Panna stock). These are our own stock figures, not a market rate, and every listing shows its own final price. For the per-ratti rates of all gemstones, see our gemstone price list and ratti calculator.
When Panna is the right choice
Choose Panna when an astrologer has recommended it for your chart, for example for Mithun or Kanya lagna, or during a Budh dasha. It is the stone the tradition actually prescribes for Budh. For astrological use we recommend natural, untreated Zambian Panna, which is deep green. Lighter, often oil-treated Colombian emerald is mainly used in jewellery. Whatever you buy, check that the lab report states natural beryl (emerald) and any treatment. Our Panna stone guide covers the full wearing rules and mantra.
When peridot makes sense
Peridot has a bright, slightly yellowish green and is accepted as a substitute for Panna. Some people simply prefer its colour or want a clean, transparent stone. The catch is price: in our stock a 5 ratti peridot and a 5 ratti entry-level Panna cost roughly the same. If the budget is similar, many buyers choose a smaller certified Panna instead. If you prefer peridot for its look, or your astrologer suggests it, it is a fair choice. See our peridot stone guide.
When green onyx makes sense
Green onyx is the most affordable Budh stone by a wide margin. At about ₹450 per ratti, even a larger stone stays within a small budget. It is often worn by students, by people trying a Budh stone for the first time, or by anyone who wants to start with a low-cost remedy before investing in Panna. It is less transparent than Panna or peridot, and it is usually worn in a slightly larger size.
What a substitute can and cannot do
In tradition, an uparatna is believed to carry a milder effect than the main ratna. We do not promise the same result from peridot or green onyx as from Panna, and we will not tell you otherwise to make a sale. A substitute is a sensible starting point, not a replacement that is “just as good”. For more on how substitutes work, read our guide to uparatna.
The wearing rules are the same for all three
- Finger: little finger of the working hand
- Metal: silver or gold
- Day: Wednesday morning, after sunrise
- Weight: a common rule is 1 ratti for every 10 kg of body weight; your chart decides the final weight
- Mantra: Om Braam Breem Braum Sah Budhaya Namah, 108 times
These are traditional practices. Results differ from person to person, and a gemstone is never a substitute for medical, financial or legal advice.
FAQ
Is peridot a substitute for Panna?
Yes. Peridot is traditionally accepted as an uparatna of Panna for Budh. At Tushar Gems its price per ratti is close to entry-level Panna, so compare both before buying.
Is green onyx as good as emerald?
No. Green onyx is a much more affordable substitute and is traditionally believed to have a milder effect. It is a good low-cost start, not an equal to Panna.
Can I wear Panna and green onyx together?
There is no need to wear two Budh stones at once. Choose one after a kundli check, and change to Panna later if your budget allows.
Which Budh stone is best for students?
Panna is the traditional choice for learning and speech. Students on a budget often start with green onyx. The right stone still depends on the birth chart, which our team checks for free.
Not sure which one suits you? Get a free kundli check, call or WhatsApp +91 95400 05349, or visit our showrooms at Gold Souk Mall, Sector 43, Gurugram, or Karol Bagh, New Delhi. Tushar Gems has dealt in natural certified gemstones since 1998.
Related guides from Tushar Gems
-
Posted in
Budh, Buying Guide, Emerald, Green Onyx, Panna, Peridot, Uparatna












